Recently encountered joke: "I don't have any skeletons in my
closet, but only because the bodies haven't rotted yet."
"The Skeleton Closet" is an absolutely charming site, and they
do a fine job with their documentation. It's just the place to
go to get something juicy to torment True Believer friends of
whatever political fancy.
However, I'm pretty sure I don't agree with their contention
that "character DOES matter". I've noticed that the losing
candidates of the last three elections (at least) have tried
to make private character an issue, and all failed miserably.
(Probably the cleverest bit of McCain's strategy is not
to lean hard on the character card.) So, at least for getting
elected, it's pretty clear that being various kinds of
slimeball isn't enough to sink you.
I also think this excessive focus on "private" character
distracts from considering and encouraging public
character, that is, the behavior of people in their
role as public official. Having the president be both
chief exec and Head of State makes it all the messier.